Wrap Up

Eight Men Out did a good job portraying the Black Sox scandal for how much it had to keep track of. There are so many moving parts and actors (both in a Hollywood sense and a historical sense) between the players, the gamblers, and everyone in between. This movie, along with the historical portrayal, falls in line with Sayles’ directing style. If I had a nickel for every time that John Sayles made a movie about a historical event from between 1919 and 1920 that was released between 1987 and 1988 with a touch of anti-big-business ideology, I would have two nickels, which is not a lot, but it is weird that it happened twice. The baseball scenes are not faked, which is good in some ways, but the pitches look like a 12-year-old could hit them and the batters swing and miss by three feet sometimes. Several times throughout the movie the 1919 White Sox are referred to as something along the lines of the greatest team of all time. To me, that sentiment encompasses the historical accuracy of this movie to a tee. It is easy for me to look back at this movie and say that these things are wrong or confusing, just like it is easy for me to look back at the 1919 White Sox and say that they were not the greatest team of all time. However, just because the 1919 White Sox are not the greatest team of all time, does not mean they were not great, and the same can be said about this movie.