Primary Source Analysis

John Sayles is an independent filmmaker/director who has made several films, mostly throughout the 1980s and 1990s.[1] Sayles directed Matewan, which we analyzed in class, which came out one year before Eight Men Out and there are noticeable similarities between the two films, despite being so different on the surface. Both Matewan and Eight Men Out depict a series of events that occur in the immediate aftermath of WWI dealing with class conflict. One of the choices that Sayles makes for Eight Men Out is to depict the players as the victims/protagonists in the story. This choice reveals another key similarity between the two movies: class conflict. In Matewan, it is the coal company versus the coal miners, and in Eight Men Out it is the stingy team owner versus the exploited baseball players. This choice to depict the corrupt baseball players as victims of exploitative ownership is strange in a vacuum, but with the context of Sayles’ filmmaking, it becomes clear why he made that choice. Sayles was very against big corporations and how much control they had over America in the late 1980s.[2] His message with these two movies is a critique of the rich/ruling class and the control they had. In a literal sense with Eight Men Out, the story is about greedy people corrupting America’s pastime, and in this sense, Sayles is not subtle with his anti-big-business message.

Another contemporary influence more specific to baseball was the MLB cocaine epidemic of the 1980s. Major League Baseball players were abusing the party drug with high commonality and regularity throughout the 1980s.[3] The league stood idly by and hardly enforced any protocols or tests due to the game on the field not being affected and the strong resistance from the player’s association. Sayles would have witnessed this phenomenon and could have picked a story where the ballplayer’s actions had serious consequences.

1.) “John Sayles,” IMDb, accessed November 18, 2024, https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000626/.

2.) Jeffrey McClurken, “Matewan,” History 329: US History in Film (class lecture, University of Mary Washington, Fredericksburg, VA, October 29, 2024).

3.) Craig Greenham, “Snowed: How MLB and the MLBPA Mishandled the Cocaine Problem of the 1980s,” Sport History Review 47, no 1. (2016): 69-70, doi:10.1123/shr.2015-0019.